When someone is diagnosed with breast cancer, one of the biggest questions is — Which surgery is better for breast cancer? Should you go for a lumpectomy or a mastectomy? The decision can be emotional and confusing. This guide by Dr. Lalit Banswal, one of the best breast cancer surgeon in Pune, will help you understand both procedures and choose the right one for your situation.
This blog explains:
- What lumpectomy and mastectomy mean?
- When each surgery is recommended?
- How recovery and risks differ?
- How to make the best choice for your health?
What Are Lumpectomy and Mastectomy?
Both lumpectomy and mastectomy are surgical procedures to treat breast cancer, but they differ in scope.
- Lumpectomy: This surgery removes only the tumor and a small margin of surrounding healthy tissue. It aims to preserve most of the breast. It is often followed by radiation therapy.
- Mastectomy: This involves removing the entire breast to eliminate or prevent cancer spread. It may be recommended for more advanced or recurrent cancers.
If you are searching for lumpectomy in Pune or mastectomy in Pune, understanding these differences is the first step in making an informed decision.
When Is Lumpectomy Suitable?
A lumpectomy is usually suitable for patients with early-stage breast cancer or a small tumor that hasn’t spread. It’s ideal if:
- The cancer is confined to one area.
- You want to preserve your breast’s natural appearance.
- You can undergo radiation therapy after surgery.
For many women, lumpectomy is a safe and effective option, supported by studies showing similar survival rates to mastectomy for early-stage cases. So, if you wonder, “Is lumpectomy safe?” — the answer is yes, when performed by an experienced surgeon like Dr. Lalit Banswal.
When Is Mastectomy the Better Option?
A mastectomy may be recommended if:
- The tumor is large compared to the breast size.
- Cancer has spread to multiple areas of the breast.
- There’s a strong family history or genetic risk (like BRCA mutation).
- You’ve had radiation before or can’t undergo it again.
Patients who undergo mastectomy in Pune can also explore reconstruction after mastectomy, which helps restore the breast shape and boost confidence.
Factors Influencing the Choice:
Choosing between lumpectomy and mastectomy depends on:
- Stage and size of cancer
- Breast size and shape
- Genetic or family risk factors
- Personal preference
- Doctor’s recommendation
At Precision Plus Superspeciality Hospital, Dr. Lalit Banswal helps patients understand these factors clearly before making a decision.
Risks, Outcomes, and Recovery Comparison:
Every surgery has some level of risk.
- Lumpectomy risks: Minor pain, swelling, or changes in breast shape.
- Mastectomy risks: Longer recovery, possible numbness, and emotional impact.
However, both surgeries have excellent outcomes when performed by a skilled breast cancer doctor. The recovery period may vary — lumpectomy patients often recover faster, while mastectomy patients may take a few weeks longer.
Regardless of the option, patients receiving breast cancer treatment in Pune from Dr. Lalit Banswal report faster recovery and minimal complications.
Reconstruction Options After Mastectomy:
Modern breast reconstruction techniques allow women to restore their breast shape using implants or tissue from their own body. These options can be done immediately after mastectomy or later, based on medical advice.
At Precision Plus Superspeciality Hospital, advanced reconstruction is available under the guidance of Dr. Lalit Banswal, making it one of the best cancer hospitals in Pune.
How to Decide What’s Right for You?
Choosing between lumpectomy and mastectomy depends on your cancer stage, health, and personal comfort.
Discuss openly with your surgeon about:
- Expected outcomes
- Treatment timeline
- Long-term monitoring
Dr. Lalit Banswal, a leading breast cancer doctor in Pune, provides a personalized approach, helping patients make confident and informed decisions about their surgery.
Conclusion:
Both lumpectomy and mastectomy play vital roles in breast cancer surgery options. The right choice depends on medical factors and your personal comfort. With guidance from Dr. Lalit Banswal, the best cancer surgeon in Pune, patients receive expert care and compassionate support at every stage — from diagnosis to recovery.
If you’re considering lumpectomy in Pune or mastectomy in Pune, book a consultation with Dr. Lalit Banswal today and take a confident step towards recovery.